The Greene Room
For centuries, lawyers have been blaming God for things that go wrong. Earthquakes, hurricanes, floods and other natural disasters have traditionally qualified as potential force majeure events — circumstances beyond the parties’ control that may excuse contractual performance. But now there’s a new player in the game: artificial intelligence. And unlike God, AI comes with a user agreement.
As AI becomes increasingly embedded in commercial lending, equipment leasing, underwriting, servicing and payment processing, an interesting legal question emerges: Can an AI-related failure constitute a force majeure event, excusing a party’s failure to perform its contractual obligations? Or, to put it another way, when the computer says no, does the law say maybe?
What Exactly is Force Majeure?
Force majeure, French for “superior force,” generally refers to extraordinary events beyond the parties’ control that prevent or substantially interfere with contractual performance. Most commercial contracts contain provisions identifying events such as natural disasters, wars, government actions and other circumstances beyond the reasonable control of the affected party. But courts have generally been reluctant to excuse contractual obligations simply because performance has become more difficult or expensive.
California Civil Code Section 1511, for example, recognizes certain circumstances that excuse performance, including prevention or delay caused by an “irresistible, superhuman cause,” unless the parties have expressly agreed otherwise. Whether AI qualifies as superhuman is perhaps a question better left to philosophers. Whether it qualifies as irresistible is another matter entirely.
When AI Goes Rogue
Consider a commercial lender whose AI-powered underwriting platform suddenly malfunctions, preventing it from funding approved transactions. Or an equipment leasing company whose automated servicing system incorrectly calculates payments, generates erroneous default notices or fails to process payments. Perhaps a financing broker’s AI platform experiences a catastrophic outage, or an AI-driven payment system mistakenly transfers millions of dollars to the wrong account.
In each case, the affected party might argue that the disruption was beyond its reasonable control and therefore constitutes a force majeure event. But would that argument succeed? Probably not, at least not automatically.
One important consideration is whether the event was foreseeable and whether the parties allocated the risk in their contract. And therein lies the problem with AI. Unlike an earthquake, AI is technology that businesses voluntarily adopt and increasingly depend upon. Its risks are hardly a secret. AI systems malfunction, generate inaccurate information and produce unexpected results. Can a lender that voluntarily entrusts critical operations to AI subsequently claim that its failure was unforeseeable?
Perhaps. A truly extraordinary external disruption might qualify under a sufficiently broad contractual provision. But ordinary software failures, faulty programming, inadequate oversight or misplaced reliance on AI-generated information are much more likely to be characterized as business risks rather than acts of God. There is a substantial difference between an unavoidable catastrophe and a preventable technological failure.
What About the Borrower’s Obligations?
Suppose a borrower’s AI-dependent business suffers a catastrophic technological failure, destroying its ability to generate revenue. Can the borrower invoke force majeure to avoid payments under its equipment lease or commercial loan? Generally speaking, that would be a difficult argument.
Courts distinguish between circumstances preventing contractual performance and those merely impairing a party’s financial ability to perform. In West Pueblo Partners, LLC v. Stone Brewing Co., LLC (2023), the California Court of Appeal rejected a tenant’s attempt to avoid rent obligations based on pandemic-related business disruptions where the tenant retained the ability to pay. Similar reasoning could apply to an AI-related interruption.
A borrower whose automated business systems collapse may have a serious operational problem, but that does not necessarily excuse its obligation to repay the lender. After all, the lender financed the equipment or advanced the money. It did not guarantee the borrower’s technological competence.
Time to Rewrite the Boilerplate?
As AI becomes more deeply integrated into commercial finance, lenders, lessors, brokers and their attorneys should consider whether existing force majeure provisions adequately address technological disruptions. Traditional boilerplate may not distinguish between external cyberattacks, widespread network outages, third-party AI failures and problems caused by a company’s own technology.
Parties should consider expressly addressing AI-related failures, notice requirements, reasonable backup systems and which obligations remain enforceable despite technological disruptions. Particular attention should be paid to payment obligations, which lenders will generally want excluded from force majeure relief. Reliance on AI should not automatically relieve a party of responsibility for its contractual performance.
The Bottom Line
AI is changing commercial finance, and it may eventually change how courts interpret contractual risk. But AI is not a deity, and its failures are not necessarily acts of God. For now, AI-related disruptions should be evaluated under traditional principles of contract interpretation, foreseeability, causation and allocation of risk.
The mere fact that a machine made the mistake does not mean nobody is responsible.
And if your AI system tells you otherwise, you might want to consult an actual lawyer.
Preferably one who hasn’t been replaced by a chatbot.
Ken Greene works at Law Offices of Kenneth Charles Greene.

