Barriers to Bank M&A Remain High, Market Uncertainty Stalls Growth Plans
NOV 18, 2020 - 7:33 am
Bank Director, an information resource for directors and officers of financial institutions, released its 2021 Bank M&A Survey, sponsored by Crowe. Findings indicated that the barriers to dealmaking may prove difficult to surmount in today’s uncertain economic and political environment.
“Despite pressures on credit quality and profitability, the majority of respondents say that they’re not any more likely to sell their bank,” Emily McCormick, vice president of research at Bank Director, said. “Most are confident that their bank can weather this crisis. That optimism may fuel their desire to remain independent — at least until pricing improves.”
The 2021 Bank M&A Survey dove into how the current environment has affected bank M&A and growth plans. In response to the uncertain landscape, 63% of respondents pointed to concerns about the quality of a potential target’s loan book as a top barrier to making an acquisition, which was up from last year’s survey (36%).
More than one third said their institution is likely to purchase a bank by the end of 2021; this represents a decline compared to last year’s survey when 44% believed an acquisition was likely in 2020.
“Some say that 2020 is the year that never was due to the pandemic. This has been demonstrated in bank M&A, with fewer deals during the pandemic period of 2020,” Rick Childs, a partner at Crowe, said. “Still, some of the truisms of the past continue: There are more buyers than sellers, price is an issue and many banks prefer organic growth. What has changed is that credit is king again, CECL is a significant factor, the future of the economy is unknown and credit due diligence is once again a hot topic.”
Key Survey Findings
Loan Losses – More than half of respondents (57%) believe their bank’s loan loss allowance will be sufficient to cover expected losses over the next 12 months.
Willing to Pay for Quality – When describing their bank’s acquisition strategy, 44% indicated that they seek strategic acquisitions, regardless of price. One quarter look for low-priced acquisitions of historically well-run banks, and 27% are comfortable paying a premium for well-managed banks.
Tech Acquisitions Rare – Just 11% believe they’ll purchase a technology company. Of these, 63% expressed interest in buying a business or commercial lending platform, while 63% are open to acquiring a consumer deposit-gathering platform. Almost half are seeking data analytics capabilities.
Price Remains a Barrier – Potential acquirers’ concerns about pricing as a barrier to dealmaking have dropped from 72% last year to 60% in this year’s survey. However, more respondents expressed concern about their ability to use stock as currency in a deal, as well as demands on their capital should they acquire.
Effects on Capital – Most believe their bank’s capital levels are sufficient to weather the economic downturn, assuming a rapid (98%) or slow (98%) recovery in 2021, or a mild recession (97%). Eighty-one percent believe they can weather a deeper recession. Just one quarter plan to raise capital over the next six months.
The survey includes the views of 241 directors, CEOs and CFOs of U.S. banks.
Is it too late to heal the cancer created by mishandled early payoffs? Early payoffs are living entities in the organization of equipment finance. They show dynamic patterns based on the interaction of the hosts: vendors, brokers and lenders. Observing... read more
Tim Moriarity is “second generation” in the equipment finance business, following in his father’s footsteps, but his path has been strategic. Always on the marketing side in direct sales, sales management and vendor development, Moriarity worked with senior industry veterans... read more