Equipment Leasing and Finance Association 2009 Investor Conference

by Susan Carol May/June 2009
Despite the global financial crisis in which assets fell by $50 trillion since last year and the industry was facing its 15th month in recession, at the March 19 ELFA/IMN Investor Conference in New York, attendees expressed some hope and optimism.

Some industry executives were pinning hope on a program called TALF (Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facilities), saying it will increase liquidity and help them survive an extended recession, which no one predicted would end soon.

Others seemed to have pinned their hopes on the creation of depository banks to increase access to funds. Some are leaving the industry, or their parent companies are shedding the financing arm, and the eighth annual event had 100 fewer attendees than the year before.

There was considerable discussion about TALF and midway through the conference — attendees were checking their Blackberrys to report that the asset-backed securities program created by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York was expanding to include ABS transactions backed by equipment leases and loans, beyond the consumer asset categories first identified for this program, which were auto and retail primarily.

There are limitations with TALF. For example, the nonrecourse debt loans to investors in asset-backed securities must show that they have triple-A ratings, and have scores from two rating agencies. Joe Nachbin, a principal with The Alta Group, said the FICA score had to be 680 for auto loans, but he added, “We don’t know yet what is required for equipment leases and loans. How challenging this requirement is depends on how they define ‘Triple A.’” Some said the TALF won’t be a panacea and others expressed pessimism about having the Feds as a partner since terms and conditions can be changed by them at any time.

Where the Opportunities Are
Beyond TALF, Dan Kramer, a middle-market lender with ICON Capital Corp., said ICON has good liquidity and it is opportunistic right now — looking for investments in categories ranging from manufacturers to service companies, and from mining to energy. He also noted the company is international in scope.

Stephen Whelan, a partner with Sonneschein, Nath and Rosenthal, LLP, said he was optimistic for the industry’s future “because there is real value in our sector and it never had the froth that the real estate mortgage sector had. No one ever bought a forklift with 10% down and then flipped it. There is a constant need in the economy for replacement equipment.”

Global equipment finance executives may be fairing better than others, and independents seem to remain hopeful to some extent. John Deere’s vice president of wind energy, David A. Drescher, has four years in the sector and said he believes in the potential for continued growth. He noted the company is self funded and was an early entrant in what is now a more recognized sector with government interest behind it. Concerning the energy sector, he said, “This is going to be one of the opportunities of a lifetime. This is a green tsunami and I think this is a good one.”

Ed Castagna, president of Nassau Asset Management, a speaker at the investor conference, said people are seeing that on the positive side there is great skilled labor in the market now. He added that his company has recently hired two executives to expand its collections division. Another CEO, Roland Chalons-Browne, of Siemens Financial Services, said he too was interested in acquiring certain skill sets for this global company.

Seeking a Clear Path
No one speculated on when the economic downturn would hit a bottom or when a reset would occur. Paul Sinsheimer, president and CEO of Financial Federal Corporation, said, “No one knows where we are [referring to the industry] or what to do when all of my lenders are broke.” He said his company will endure because it didn’t rely solely on securitization and it didn’t rely on credit scoring, which he suggested is outsourcing underwriting, a critical function. He advises staying in the game and finding a clear path. “Today is pretty ugly, but this will pass.”

A clear path was described by Charles Willis, president and CEO of Willis Lease Finance Corporation, of Novato, CA. He said his company’s focus on jet engine leasing remains strong because these are fuel efficient and continue to hold value in a worldwide spare engine pool shared by his clients — major commercial carriers such as American, Delta and Alaska Airlines. He said engines are more likely to be leased in down times and that it has saved three major airlines more than $120 million. Airlines share the spare engines among themselves rather than going it alone, with Willis acting as the conduit.

Though there may be higher returns for investors elsewhere right now, speakers on a panel lead by Daniel Marino, first vice president, DZ Bank, said that there are pockets of opportunity. There are portfolios that banks are selling as they return to core businesses and others with now out-of-favor assets, such as in trucking. Frank Cirone, senior vice president of Relational Technology Solutions, says the A-rated portfolios may not be on the market yet. “We are niche oriented, so we have some focused targets in mind,” he added.

Craig Weinewuth, president and chief executive officer of Mericap Credit Corporation, said his company is taking advantage of the current downturn to grow through acquiring assets, rather than relying just on origination as was his original strategy. He added, though, that due diligence is “extreme.” Most of what he is seeing are sellers that are seeking to improve their liquidity. “No one wants to make a mistake,” he said.

On the subject of opportunities to acquire portfolios, Mike Lockwood, managing director of Aequitas Capital Management, said the company is seeing opportunities come through regional banks, but in all situations it evaluates collections practices, underwriting and standards used in documentation. Marino produced four slides outlining the types of deals this panel has seen in the current distressed market. These included a distressed seller of diversified small-ticket leases. There was a partial platform transfer and the purchaser’s source of funds was a hedge fund. Another example was a small-ticket leasing portfolio being sold to increase funding capability for the seller. The third example involved middle-ticket leasing of out-of-favor assets.

Miles Herman, president and chief operating officer of Leaf Financial Corporation, commented on the importance of understanding the seller’s motivation and the human side concerning the management approach and whether the portfolio is “core to our business or enabling new areas of growth.” He also noted how important the integration of portfolios becomes. In considering portfolios for sales, he asks two key questions: “Is there an adviser on the other side and are they realistic? and What about the training of the people?”

Andrea Petro, executive vice president of Wells Fargo Foothill, said “As a nation, our competitive advantage has always been that we could get financing out to the whole spectrum of businesses.” But with all of the government intervention she said she is concerned about a lasting impact on capital markets. “Intellectual capital will migrate to where it can be utilized.” She said her company is bullish in certain segments, but it is looking for one-year track records with a minimal number of write-offs.

Mark McCall, managing director of Suntrust Robinson Humphrey, said his bank’s view is that there are people running good businesses and money needs to get out to the small- and medium-sized businesses. “My view on the economy is irrelevant to what I am doing in the market.” He said he is focusing on finding new sources for the companies he has relationships with and that there are at least “short-term runways.”


Susan Carol is a communications professional with 20 years of experience in equipment leasing and finance. For more information, visit www.scapr.com.

Leave a comment

No tags available